Q&A for How to Tell When an Egg Is Boiled

Return to Full Article

Search
Add New Question
  • Question
    What does a bad egg look like?
    Ollie George Cigliano
    Private Chef & Food Educator
    Ollie George Cigliano is a Private Chef, Food Educator, and Owner of Ollie George Cooks, based in Long Beach, California. With over 20 years of experience, she specializes in utilizing fresh, fun ingredients and mixing traditional and innovative cooking techniques. Ollie George holds a BA in Comparative Literature from The University of California, Berkeley, and a Nutrition and Healthy Living Certificate from eCornell University.
    Private Chef & Food Educator
    Expert Answer
    Fill a bowl with cool water and place the eggs into the water. If they float, they are bad and should be discarded. The ones in the bottom are good. If you are worried you won”t be able to tell or that some might be in the middle, have no fear: some eggs will not lay on their side at the bottom “fresh zone”, and kind of nod up, but still stay at the bottom. These are about a week old, but still good.
  • Question
    What is the easiest way to remove the egg shells after boiling?
    Community Answer
    When the egg is still warm, pat or roll the egg on a countertop. Starting at one end, peel in a circular motion.
  • Question
    Why would an egg rise to top of pot while it is being boiled?
    Community Answer
    If an egg floats to the top at any point, it means the egg has gone bad and you should discard it.
  • Question
    One of the eggs I boiled was not done enough. Can I return it to the water with the others, so it can cook some more?
    Community Answer
    Yes. Cook it for another minute or two, and keep an eye on it.
  • Question
    My hard boiled eggs are firm but look like they should have cooked a bit longer. Can they be reboiled or are they safe to eat like they are?
    Community Answer
    As long as the white is firm, the egg can be eaten with a soft yolk. Eggs are specifically prepared with runny yolks for certain dishes, like Ramen noodles. You can re-boil them, but you risk turning your eggs rubbery.
  • Question
    If I wish to use hard-boiled eggs 12 hours after cooking, should they be shelled?
    Community Answer
    Yes. Boil the eggs, remove the shells, then refrigerate the eggs until you plan to eat them.
  • Question
    How do I know when eggs are done boiling?
    Stuart Riddle
    Community Answer
    It depends if you want hard or soft eggs. Hard boiled eggs take no more than 8 minutes from boiling, and soft take about 3.5 minutes. Mostly, practice makes perfect, as all eggs are different sizes.
  • Question
    What are different ways to remove an eggshell?
    Community Answer
    Use about 2 tablespoons of salt in the water when cooking them. The shells will come right off, even with fresh eggs.
  • Question
    How long can I keep my hard boiled eggs in the fridge?
    Community Answer
    I would say no more than 6 or 7 days in a tightly closed container, just for the freshness factor.
  • Question
    What is an easy way to make a good dinner with boiled eggs?
    Community Answer
    You can use them in salads. If you cut them into cubes, you can also make a great egg sandwich by adding mayonnaise and spices to taste.
  • Question
    Why do some eggshells peel off easy and some are impossible?
    Community Answer
    What I do is boil the eggs using cool tap water (adding a tablespoon of salt can help make shells easier to remove), turn to medium-high heat until it's a rolling boil, then let sit for 10 minutes. Put them into a bowl of ice water for 10 minutes, which makes the whole egg contract. Next, put them two at a time into the still-hot water for 1 minute to expand the shell, but not the egg inside; this allows easier removal of the shell, as the inside is smaller than the shell now. Keep adding cold eggs to the warm water two at a time as you peel them.
  • Question
    How long do boiled eggs last?
    Community Answer
    1 week in the fridge, 2 days if not refrigerated but not in the sun. In the sun, 6 hours max.
  • Question
    Before I color eggs, should I leave them out or refrigerate them first?
    Community Answer
    Out, because the color absorbs more when warm, and it doesn't stick as well if the egg is cold.
  • Question
    I just colored boiled Easter eggs, accidentally I colored a raw one as well, now I don't know which one is the raw one. What should I do?
    Community Answer
    Spin them. The raw one will wobble and stop because of the liquid inside. The hard boiled will spin freely.
Ask a Question

      Return to Full Article