Q&A for How to Break off an Engagement

Return to Full Article

Search
Add New Question
  • Question
    How can I tell if I should break up with my fiance?
    Cherlyn Chong
    Relationship Coach
    Cherlyn Chong is a breakup recovery and dating coach. With 6 years of experience, she specializes in working with high-achieving professional women who want to get over their exes and find love again. She has experience as an official coach for The League dating app, and has been featured on AskMen, Business Insider, Reuters and HuffPost.
    Relationship Coach
    Expert Answer
    This can be really difficult to figure out, but you want to look out for red flags. If they're always trash talking their exes or they seem really resentful, it could be a sign that they aren't mature enough to be married. Another sign could be if they're always talking about themselves. If you're worried about dog being sick and they turn around and start talking about a dog they had growing up, that's a bad sign. A lot of this comes down to your gut, though. If you're thinking about breaking up with your fiance, it's definitely a sign you aren't ready to get married, though. At bare minimum, push the wedding back while you evaluate your feelings.
  • Question
    I am engaged and the wedding date is very near, but I don't want to marry her. What should I say to cancel the marriage?
    Community Answer
    This will be difficult, but if you don't want to marry this person, you must let her know this before it's too late. Explain that you are not ready for marriage and need to be on your own to figure some things out. She will not want to accept this, but it is for her own good that she not be married to a person who does not love her. She will understand it eventually.
  • Question
    I've been engaged for nearly a year to a man I have known for 7 years. He still hasn't gotten a stable job. An old boyfriend contacted me and I want to explore that. What do I say to my fiance?
    Community Answer
    If you're sure about this, it's best to just tell your fiance, "I can't marry you because I still have feelings for someone else." Be honest and direct. If you think you'd like to try to make things work with your fiance, tell him in no uncertain terms that he needs to get a job immediately or the engagement is off.
  • Question
    I have been engaged to my fiance for two months. I love him, but I'm tired of being pressured to do things. He tries forcing me to quit smoking cigarettes by guilt-tripping. Plus, I still love my ex. What do I do?
    Tom De Backer
    Top Answerer
    Think back to your reasons of accepting the engagement, it's not the same level of decision as what to have for dinner tonight. You also still loved your ex when you made this decision. If we can't choose between two partners, the best choice is usually neither of them. But that's up to you. A big red flag is the pressure, it may likely never stop even if you do quit smoking. He may just learn that he can mold you into the person he'd like, plus it robs you of the chance to quit smoking on your own accord. No one can ever force anyone to do anything; those who try will end up disillusioned.
  • Question
    We've been in a relationship for 5 years and are still together. I just got engaged to him and the wedding is soon, but I don't want to go through with it because he is saying rude and hurtful things to me.
    Community Answer
    You should try talking to him about this first. Maybe he just has really bad jitters about the wedding? Tell him that you don't appreciate the way he's been talking to you lately, and that it's making you feel like you shouldn't be getting married to him. Ask him to go to couple's counseling to work on this issue. If he doesn't apologize and agree to go to counseling, break off the engagement.
  • Question
    I am engaged, but am not as happy as I should be. I know I should call it off, but am scared. She is highly emotional in conflict and has a parent with a fatal illness with little time. I feel stuck, what do I do?
    Tom De Backer
    Top Answerer
    If you're truly unhappy, let nothing stand in your way to end the engagement; in truth, it sounds like you're letting your (un)happiness have too much of an effect on your long-term decisions. Whether her parent is sick is irrelevant to how you feel, as is her being emotional. You're not stuck at all, simply end it if you want to end it.
  • Question
    I got engaged two months ago to my boyfriend but I don't want to get married now, mostly because I don't feel ready mentally. I've told him this but he sees no reason to it at all.
    Community Answer
    if he wants to get married and he really loves you, then he should understand and help you through it. You are being honest and self-reflective about your preparedness for marriage and if he cannot appreciate that, then he isn't ready either. Don't let him force you into something you'll later regret, life is too short, youth even shorter.
  • Question
    I got engaged with my boyfriend. Now when I am not feeling this relation is good. So I tried to do things right but everything is ending in a fight. Advice?
    Community Answer
    Maybe you both are too young or are just stressed with whatever else is happening in the background in both your lives. If after making effort, everything still goes wrong yet you feel there's hope, then there may be hope. You both need me time to grow and become stronger so you can shoulder the heavy responsibility of marriage. Try getting some counseling together to work through your issues. It is better to work out compatibility before marrying than to find you don't get along after marriage.
  • Question
    Long distance relationship, then we got engaged after a year but now it doesn’t feel right. She moved from Brazil to the US with her son. She gets mad at me but won’t tell me why. Not sure now. Advice?
    Community Answer
    With time, the person's real intentions and issues reveal themselves. These issues need to be addressed first before you are sure whether you want to leave, so you can gain closure. Try to talk to her about it, keep it civil, and be honest about your feelings. Tell her that you cannot wait around any longer and need to know an answer.
  • Question
    I got engaged 3 months ago in a 6-month relationship. I actually had to finance the ring and put money down on it. He owes me back rent. He's not forthcoming about his debt. What should I do?
    Community Answer
    Now that he knows you've paid for so many things without him contributing or shouldering half of it, he may want to have it all as time goes by too. If you see him striving to earn well, he may have bigger plans. If he seems to dodge his responsibility, you may be getting married to someone who will just sit and eat and expect you to do all the financial work. Is that what you want? Discuss your feelings with him; his true colors are showing and this is a warning to you.
  • Question
    I got engaged one year ago but now my fiancee is pregnant with someone else's child. What do I do?
    Community Answer
    It depends on you. If that someone isn't offering to help raise and support your fiancee, then it would be up to you to help her (if you can forgive her). You'll need to talk to her about the possibilities and how this infidelity has hurt and affected you, and then discuss what you two as a couple are going to be. If you no longer feel the relationship is one you have faith in, then it would probably be best for you to break off the engagement and start over.
  • Question
    I said yes but was unsure. He was going on a trip, and I thought we’d have time to talk when he came back, but he ended up moving there to be with his daughter and wants me to come. I don’t want to be a mom.
    Community Answer
    Talk to your fiancé about your concerns. You might be able to work out something else. Otherwise, you may end up having to break things off.
Ask a Question

      Return to Full Article