Q&A for How to Make Oxygen and Hydrogen from Water Using Electrolysis

Return to Full Article

Search
Add New Question
  • Question
    Is this activity safe for sixth grade?
    Dragg
    Community Answer
    It all depends on the safety precautions taken during the experiment. Hydrogen is easily flammable and requires oxygen to burn. Before presenting the experiment in front of the class, make sure you understand the process. Safety equipment like as goggles and gloves are recommended.
  • Question
    Would it be safe to breathe in chloride?
    Community Answer
    No. Chloride is an extremely dangerous gas, and should not be inhaled under any circumstances. Fortunately, there will only be a tiny bit of chloride present in this experiment and should not cause you much harm--unless you use a very high voltage battery. Nonetheless, it would be a good idea to avoid inhaling any chloride gases, regardless of the amount.
  • Question
    How do I store hydrogen gas separately?
    Community Answer
    Hydrogen is less dense than oxygen so it should rise to the top of the container, though you would not be able to see it. With this in mind, theoretically if you used a bottle rather than a cup and had a small tube to run the hydrogen off with you could potentially store the hydrogen separately. Though hydrogen is highly flammable/can be explosive, so it's not recommended to store in large quantities. If you want to start getting technical, there are also sensors you can buy that recognize the presence of O2 and H2, which you could use in addition to small pumps so you could separate the hydrogen made and use it as a fuel source.
  • Question
    Is this activity safe for kids around 5th grade?
    Community Answer
    Hydrogen gas is extremely flammable and will burn whenever oxygen is introduced so if you do this, make sure an competent adult who understands the process is included.
  • Question
    I've tried this but no effects are noticeable. I have added salt and checked the battery for power. How can I fix this?
    Community Answer
    You could try moving the electrodes closer together. If they are far away then electricity won't conduct. Also, you can try using baking soda instead of salt.
  • Question
    What does 4e- and 4H+ mean in the reaction 2 H2O > 4e- + 4H+ + O2?
    Community Answer
    4e- is the transfer of electrons and the 4H+ shows that the hydrogen has an overall positive charge from losing its electrons. The process can be predicted from the periodic table. Hydrogen has a lower electron affinity, so it will lose its electrons before oxygen. Affinity moves from left to right and bottom to top. Flourine has the highest affinity. The electric current is the energy that frees the electrons, breaking the bond between Hydrogen and the Oxygen.
  • Question
    If Hydrogen is oxidized will it ignite?
    Dragg
    Community Answer
    Hydrogen will not ignite when it's combined with oxygen. However, oxygen will feed the flame.
  • Question
    Will this activity be dangerous for a fourth grade science project?
    Community Answer
    Yes! It is dangerous because hydrogen is highly flammable and O2 will only feed the flame.
  • Question
    How do I filter off oxygen from the chloride gas?
    Community Answer
    You can't.
  • Question
    Does the hydrogen make the wire look rusted?
    Community Answer
    Yes, it will make the wire look rusted.
  • Question
    How can I turn the gas to liquid?
    Dtown2002
    Community Answer
    You will need to put the gas in a place with a very, very cold temperature because gas's boiling points are very low. Once you lower it under the boiling point, you have liquid oxygen or hydrogen.
  • Question
    How can I separate hydrogen for making hydrogen fuel?
    Community Answer
    Simply put the funnel and glass above. Imagine that hydrogen is water, but it flows up instead of down. Hydrogen will settle in the glass.
  • Question
    If I submerge two small glasses in the same manner and in the larger glass is baking soda and water and place each wire under each small glass, will one be breathable oxygen?
    Community Answer
    No. You would end up with CO2. Most processes that split H2O to breathable O2 use high pressure steam through an electrolysis process, no electrolyte involved.
  • Question
    After electrolysis, is all the water consumed?
    Startrekker
    Community Answer
    Rate of electrolysis directly depends on the conductivity, the voltage, and the surface area of electrodes. Considering you do something similar to this article, it will take a very, very long time for all water in the container to get consumed.
  • Question
    Is there a way that you could collect the hydrogen by modifying this design?
    Startrekker
    Community Answer
    Bubbles are less dense than water. So they float up. You just need to figure out a way so that the bubbles go and get collected in a container without escaping into the atmosphere. Simply invert a test tube and submerge it over the electrode.
  • Question
    Won't chlorine be produced instead of oxygen? 2H2O + 2NaCl -> 2NaHO + H2 + Cl2.
    Startrekker
    Community Answer
    Yes, if you use table salt. Consider using baking soda to produce oxygen instead of chlorine at the anode.
  • Question
    Can you identify which pole (anode and cathode) the pencil is representing? If so, how can you tell?
    Startrekker
    Community Answer
    The one connected to the positive terminal of the battery is the anode. If you observe carefully, the pole which produces more gas/bubbles is the cathode.
  • Question
    Can I store hydrogen in small amounts without air?
    Community Answer
    You can with a different setup. Use a paper cup, stick the pencils through the bottom of the cup, until half way, fill the cup with the salt water and put 2 water filled test tubes and put one mouth facing down on one of the pencils, and do that again with the other, the pencil that you connected to (-) will be hydrogen, and (+) will be oxygen.
  • Question
    Is the leftover substance in the vessel sodium hydroxide? If it is, would it be harmful?
    Community Answer
    Some, but not very much, would be left. It might be irritating though. The reason is that (-) is generating some NaOH while (+) is generating less HCl, so it neutralizes.
  • Question
    How do I collect the two gases?
    Community Answer
    Use a test tube over the pencils. Then pouch a hole in the bottom and lend it to a bottle for storage.
  • Question
    Is there a way to make H and O with this instead of H2 and O2? If so, how?
    Community Answer
    Hydrogen and oxygen are diatomic, so they will naturally pair up in groups of two.
  • Question
    Is oxygen safe to inhale?
    Community Answer
    Human beings inhale oxygen all day long, the air around you has a twenty percent oxygen ratio, so it is safe to inhale. However, you should be careful because it can ignite and cause severe damage very easily.
  • Question
    Is there more oxygen in fresh water or in seawater?
    Community Answer
    There is no difference, both are water (H2O). The difference is that seawater is saltier than freshwater.
  • Question
    If there is more salt in the water, is there more oxygen and hydrogen?
    Community Answer
    No, there is a fixed amount of hydrogen and oxygen, which you can obtain from the water. However, adding salt would increase the conductivity and make it easier for electrons to flow, so would definitely speed up the process and increase the amount being produced at any one time.
  • Question
    If I burn hydrogen, will I use it up? Would there be less hydrogen on the planet?
    Community Answer
    When hydrogen burns, it combines with oxygen in the atmosphere and produces water. The heat may also cause the nitrogen in the air around the flame to combine with oxygen in the air to produce small amounts of oxides of nitrogen.
Ask a Question

      Return to Full Article