PDF download Download Article
Easy fixes for missing puzzle pieces
PDF download Download Article

So you’ve spent the afternoon putting together a jigsaw puzzle, but then the unthinkable happens—after looking everywhere, you realize that there’s a missing piece. We’re here to help you replace it by showing you how to make a new puzzle piece using an image printed off your computer and basic crafting supplies. We'll also share resources you can use to buy replacement puzzle pieces on the internet.

How to Replace Missing Puzzle Pieces

Craft a replacement puzzle piece by printing out a high-resolution image of the puzzle art, tracing an outline of the missing piece onto the image, and cutting it out and gluing it to a piece of cardboard. Alternatively, contact the puzzle manufacturer to get replacement pieces or buy a copy of the same puzzle.

Section 1 of 2:

How to Make a Missing Puzzle Piece

PDF download Download Article
  1. To scan it, place the puzzle box or the poster that came with it image-side down onto a high-quality scanner. Run the scanner and follow the instructions that came with it to upload and save the scanned image to your computer files. [1]
    • If you don't have a scanner, take a photo of the puzzle art on the box or the poster with your mobile device. Snap the image in an area with good lighting and ensure no glare reflects off the box's or poster's surface.
  2. In a free photo editing software like GIMP or Canva , click on the Crop tool. Select a point near the part of the image where the missing puzzle piece is located and drag your mouse away to create a virtual box around the puzzle piece. Lift your finger off the mouse button, and the rest of the image outside the box you made will completely disappear.
    • Make the size of the cropped image large enough to accommodate the missing puzzle piece as well as the pieces adjacent to it on all sides. This way, when you eventually print out the image, you'll have plenty of room to trace and cut the missing piece's outline.
    Advertisement
  3. Take out your real-world puzzle and measure the length and width of the area you cropped digitally on your photo editing software in centimeters. Enter these dimensions into your photo editing software (the image resizing option is located under the Image tab in GIMP and the Position tab in Canva).
    • Resizing an image in GIMP : With your image file already opened in GIMP, click the Image tab and select Scale Image. Use the dropdown menu next to the dimension values to change them from pixels to centimeters. Then type in the width and height measurements you took on your puzzle and click Scale to confirm the changes. [2]
    • Resizing an image in Canva (Free Version) : Upload your image to Canva, click on the image, then select Use in Design. On the next screen, select the image and click Position on the toolbar. Scroll down to Advanced and click the lock icon to lock the aspect ratio (this lets Canva know you want to resize the entire image, not crop it). [3]
      • Use a free unit conversion calculator like UnitConverters to convert the width and height measurements you took of your puzzle to pixels. Next, copy and paste the converted numbers into the Width and Height boxes in Canva, then press Tab on your keyboard. The image should automatically resize.
    • For example, if the area surrounding the missing puzzle piece that you measured in the real world is 5 cm tall and 5 cm wide, enter this information into the software to change the cropped image's dimensions.
  4. Using matte-finish paper will make your replacement puzzle piece look more polished. However, it’s a good idea to print the image on cheap printer paper first as a test run, so you can ensure it’s the right size before wasting high-quality sheets.
    • Printing an image in GIMP : Click the File tab and select Print from the dropdown menu.
    • Printing an image in Canva : Click the Share button in the upper right corner of the design editor tool. Download the design with the resized image in it as a PNG file for the highest quality. Then open the Downloads folder in your computer files, open the PNG file in your PC or Mac's native Photos program, then select the Print option from the toolbar.
  5. Watermark wikiHow to Make a Missing Puzzle Piece
    Adjust the placement of the image to line up with the rest of the puzzle. [4] Next, use a sharp pencil to trace the shape of the missing piece onto the image.
  6. Watermark wikiHow to Make a Missing Puzzle Piece
    Spread puzzle saver glue onto the cardboard with a small paintbrush and adhere the image to it. [5] Finally, cut out the outline of the puzzle piece. To make the most precise cuts, use an X-ACTO knife . [6]
    • Ensure the cardboard is the right thickness and matches the rest of the puzzle pieces before using it as your replacement piece. If the cardboard is too thick, stack multiple pieces of a thin cereal box together instead until they reach the right thickness, then glue them together.
    • When cutting with an X-ACTO knife, place whatever you're cutting on top of a self-healing cutting mat . Never cut the material on a table or the puzzle, as the X-ACTO knife blade is sharp and could damage the surface underneath it.
  7. Watermark wikiHow to Make a Missing Puzzle Piece
    Paint or spray the acrylic sealer evenly across the piece, then let it dry for a few hours. This step will make your replacement piece look glossy and protect it from future wear and tear. It's an optional addition, but it's highly recommended to help your replacement piece blend in with the rest of the puzzle. [7]
  8. Now your puzzle is completely assembled and you can enjoy it! From here, consider gluing it together to form a display picture (and prevent any other pieces from going missing).
  9. Advertisement
Section 2 of 2:

Other Ways to Replace a Missing Puzzle Piece

PDF download Download Article
  1. Some puzzle makers, like the Art and Fable Puzzle Company , allow you to purchase individual pieces that go with your puzzle. They may ask you to upload pictures of your assembled puzzle so they can see which piece(s) is missing.
  2. Look for a service like the Jigsaw Doctor that takes requests for custom puzzle pieces, and ask them to make your missing piece. It may take a few weeks to receive the finished product, but this is a great option if you don't want to make the puzzle piece yourself or if the puzzle manufacturer doesn't offer replacements.
  3. This alternative to making your own puzzle piece makes sense if your puzzle is missing several pieces or if the original puzzle was inexpensive to begin with. Ordering individual replacement pieces can add up quickly, especially if you have to custom order them, so you may save more money by simply re-buying the puzzle.
  4. Advertisement

Expert Q&A

Ask a Question
      Advertisement

      Video

      Tips

      • When cutting out small puzzle pieces, use an X-ACTO knife to get around the tiny curves and corners more easily.
      Submit a Tip
      All tip submissions are carefully reviewed before being published
      Name
      Please provide your name and last initial
      Thanks for submitting a tip for review!
      Advertisement

      Things You’ll Need

      About This Article

      Thanks to all authors for creating a page that has been read 49,541 times.

      Reader Success Stories

      • CS TX

        Nov 30, 2022

        "Used this tutorial to "fix" a puzzle in October. Thanks for the tips!"
      Share your story

      Did this article help you?

      Advertisement