The 16 Rarest Jellycats & What Makes Them Valuable

PDF download Download Article
Check your Jellycat collection for these high-value plushies
PDF download Download Article

Jellycats are one of the cutest stuffed animals out there, so it’s no wonder collectors are searching for the rarest plushies to add to their collection. While some are easy to find, other Jellycats are scarcer due to their popularity and limited releases. Keep reading, and we’ll cover the rarest Jellycats on the market and what they’re worth as well as what makes them valuable . We also spoke with auction house owner Reyne Hirsch for advice on checking prices and selling valuable Jellycats .

Most Valuable Jellycats

  • Bashful Bunny Imogen: Up to $3,100 USD
  • Bashful Bunny Lucie : Up to $2,400 USD
  • Snowy Bear: Up to $1,500 USD
  • Bashful Bunny: Up to $885 USD depending on color
  • Poloneck Peeker Posse Bat : $450 USD
  • Linus Leopard Seal: $360 USD
Section 1 of 4:

Rarest & Most Expensive Jellycats

PDF download Download Article
  1. 1
    Bashful Bunnies The Bashful Bunny design is one of the most iconic Jellycat plushies because of its long floppy ears and soft fur. While some Bashful Bunny colors are still made and sold in stores today, limited edition colors that are no longer manufactured are worth a bit of money when they’re in good condition.
    • Recent eBay Selling Prices:
      • Blackberry: $885 USD
      • Pecan: $750 USD
      • Apricot: $750 USD
      • Mint Dot: $650 USD
      • Roberta Rabbit: $600 USD
      • Walnut: $600 USD
      • Pistachio: $500 USD
      • KiwI: $500 USD

    Meet the wikiHow Expert

    Reyne Hirsch is the co-owner of the Dallas Auction Gallery and an appraiser with over 25 years of experience.

  2. 2
    Poloneck Peeker Posse Bat The Poloneck Peeker Posse collection has a bunch of animals wearing large, puffy sweaters. The bat with its oversized pink sweater and cute fangs is a retired design that’s become really popular among collectors.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $450 USD
    Advertisement
  3. 3
    Linus Leopard Seal Linus Leopard Seal became a popular Jellycat because of its white polka-dot pattern and its cute pose lying on the ground. Because this design is no longer made, Linus has only gotten more valuable over time.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $360 USD
  4. 4
    Charlie Crow There’s a large fanbase for Charlie Crow because of his long, fluffy feathers and oversized beak sticking out. Charlie Crow is hard to find in stores due to its limited release and break in manufacturing, so it’s become pretty rare to find.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $325 USD
  5. 5
    Jackadee Pangolin Pangolins are lesser-known mammals that have scale-like armor, and the Jackadee Pangolin captures its look perfectly. Because the animal isn’t a household name, only a limited amount were made, so it can be a little tricky trying to find one now.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $300 USD
  6. 6
    Snow Dragon The Snow Dragon is one of the larger Jellycat plushies you can get so it’s extra cuddly. While the design has been discontinued, collectors still want the ice-white dragon in their collection and are willing to pay some extra money for it.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $300 USD
  7. 7
    Puffball Frog Puffballs are one of the original collections released by Jellycat, and they’re known for their round, soft bodies. The Puffball Frog has a goofy look on its face and small feet that stick out from its body, making it a popular option for collectors. Because these are considered “vintage” Jellycats, they’re rarer and cost a bit more than others.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $255 USD
  8. 8
    Amuseables Vicky Teapot & Seb Teacup The Amuseables collection is mostly inanimate objects that also make really cutesy stuffed animals. The Teapot and Teacup pairing are rare to find together in a set since they’ve been discontinued, but they’re still worth a good value on the resale market.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $158 USD
  9. 9
    Harrod’s Cheryl Cherry Cake Cheryl Cherry Cake was an exclusive Jellycat sold at the Harrod’s department store. Because it wasn’t widely released in other stores and because of its charming pink design, this plushie is pretty coveted by collectors.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $120 USD
  10. 10
    Amuseables Sandcastle The Amuseables Sandcastle is an adorable sand tower with legs. Even though it’s a more recent release, it’s still valued by collectors because the design is retired.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $115 USD
  11. 11
    Fuddlewuddle Fox There’s nothing limited or standout about Fuddlewuddle Fox, but it’s a popular design that people are still itching to add to their collection. The plushie has been retired, so it’s not found in stores anymore.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $90 USD
  12. 12
    Katie Kitten Tot Katie Kitten Tot is part of the Bunglie Jellycat collection, known for their really soft fur and seated position. Katie Kitten Tot is discontinued, but people are still drawn to this little cat’s design.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $70 USD
  13. 13
    Amuseable Sports Skateboard Nothing’s cuter than a skateboard with a little smile, right? Collectors love the unique look of Sports Skateboard, and they’re willing to pay a little extra to get their hands on one.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: $70 USD
  14. 14
    Snowy Bear Snowy Bear was a limited release that was only available in stores from 2015-2016. Only a small quantity of Snowy Bears were made, and while there are other polar bear Jellycats, these ones remain one of the hardest to find.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: No sales, but listings for $1,500 USD
  15. 15
    Bashful Bunny Lucie Bashful Bunny Lucie is a limited edition release that was part of the Bashful Bunny line. This pink and grey spotted rabbit only had a small number released, and the patterned design makes it extremely coveted.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: No sales, but listings for $2,400 USD
  16. 16
    Bashful Bunny Imogen Bashful Bunny Imogen is a discontinued model in the Bashful Bunny line. Even though other Bashful Bunnies are valuable, the long pink curly fur on Imogen makes it the most desirable in the collection.
    • Recent eBay Selling Price: No sales, but listings from $300 USD for pre-owned to $3,100 USD for brand new
    17. Advertisement
Section 2 of 4:

Why are some Jellycats so expensive?

PDF download Download Article
  1. 1
    Limited editions Only a set number of Jellycats are made when a limited edition drops, so once they’re sold out at the store, they’re only available through the resale market. Because there are so few of them in the world, the special editions are usually worth the most. [1]
  2. 2
    Retired designs Jellycat stops making some of their older designs to make way for new plushies pretty frequently. When a design gets retired, it’s no longer manufactured, so its rarity (and value) increases even more.
  3. 3
    Store exclusive releases Some department stores, like Harrod’s in the UK, have exclusive Jellycats that are only sold at their store locations. Because these plushies aren’t widely available to the public, they’re sought after by collectors and are worth more when they’re resold.
  4. 4
    Unique, high-quality designs Jellycat plushies are a little more expensive than other similar products because people are drawn to the cute designs that stand out from the crowd. Because they’re also manufactured from high-quality materials, there’s an added premium to their prices. [2]
    5. Advertisement
Section 3 of 4:

How to Check if Jellycats are Valuable

PDF download Download Article
  1. 1
    Inspect the Jellycats for missing tags or damage that could lower value. Jellycats are usually the most valuable when they’re clean, complete, and in mint condition. Carefully look over your Jellycats and note down any damage, such as rips, stains, missing tags, or normal wear and tear.
  2. 2
    Look up recent sale prices on eBay and other online sellers. Hirsch says, “Search for the exact item and look for sold listings. That shows you real-time market value.” She also mentions checking similar items and comparing their condition to the one you’re trying to sell. [4]
    3. Advertisement
Section 4 of 4:

Advice for Selling Jellycats

PDF download Download Article
  1. 1
    List your Jellycats on Facebook Marketplace or eBay. Hirsch recommends Facebook Marketplace if you want to make local sales. She notes you’ll find interested buyers, especially in big cities, without having to ship anything. For a wider audience, she says, “Ebay is a great platform for selling collectibles. It's well-established, and people use it for everything.” [6]
  2. 2
    Sell valuable Jellycats through consignment stores and auction houses. Hirsch suggests consignment shops if you don’t want to deal with shipping. She says, “They’ll handle the customers and marketing for you in exchange for a revenue split.” If you have high-value Jellycats valued over $500, she recommends contacting a local auction house. “Their commission can often be negotiated, and they have large buyer bases through their catalogs.” [7]
  3. 3
    Use secure payment methods to prevent scams. If you’re selling somewhere like eBay, only use the payment methods that are built into the site to ensure the payments go through properly. If you’re selling locally, stick to using services like Paypal, Venmo, or Zelle to ensure the money is sent right away. [8]
    • Always make sure you confirm the person’s identity before using a payment app so you don’t send or receive money from the wrong person.
    • As soon as you get a payment through an app, transfer the funds to your bank so your money is protected.
    4. Advertisement

Expert Q&A

Ask a Question
200 characters left
Include your email address to get a message when this question is answered.
Submit
      Advertisement

      Tips

      • If you plan on selling Jellycats, store them in a tote bin or bag to keep them clean and protected.
        Thanks
        Helpful 0 Not Helpful 0
      Submit a Tip
      All tip submissions are carefully reviewed before being published
      Name
      Please provide your name and last initial
      Submit
      Thanks for submitting a tip for review!
      Advertisement

      You Might Also Like

      The 14 Rarest and Most Valuable Matchbox Cars Ever Made
      How to
      Value Beanie Babies
      Which McDonald’s Toys Are Valuable? Rare Collectibles to Look For
      The Rarest & Most Expensive Littlest Pet Shops
      Advertisement

      References

      1. ↑ https://peenstraappraisal.com/the-ultimate-collectible-toys-value-guide/
      2. ↑ https://www.shs-conferences.org/articles/shsconf/pdf/2024/27/shsconf_icdeba2024_01013.pdf
      3. ↑ https://us.jellycat.com/jelly-journal/?p=how-to-keep-your-jellycat-companions-looking-their-best
      4. ↑ Reyne Hirsch. Auction House Owner. Expert Interview
      5. ↑ Reyne Hirsch. Auction House Owner. Expert Interview
      6. ↑ Reyne Hirsch. Auction House Owner. Expert Interview
      7. ↑ Reyne Hirsch. Auction House Owner. Expert Interview
      8. ↑ https://www.consumerreports.org/money/digital-payments/peer-to-peer-payment-apps-comparison-a5999129619/

      About This Article

      If you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission .

      Did this article help you?

      Advertisement