Q&A for How to Use a Prong Collar on Dogs

Return to Full Article

Search
Add New Question
  • Question
    What kind of prong collar should I get?
    Dani Pedraza
    Professional Dog Trainer
    Dani Pedraza is a Professional Dog Trainer and a Co-Owner of The Big City Woof Walker with presences in NYC and Chicago. Dani is passionate about providing personal, quality pet service and treatment and is very knowledgeable about training dogs using positive reinforcement and a force-free approach. As a Certified Dog Trainer (CCDT), Dani graduated from CATCH Canine Trainer Academy’s Master Course program.
    Professional Dog Trainer
    Expert Answer
    Make sure that you have a prong collar that is high quality—cheap collars are more likely to break and hurt your dog. A good quality one will be designed to protect your dog's trachea.
  • Question
    Do I need to work with a professional dog trainer first?
    Dani Pedraza
    Professional Dog Trainer
    Dani Pedraza is a Professional Dog Trainer and a Co-Owner of The Big City Woof Walker with presences in NYC and Chicago. Dani is passionate about providing personal, quality pet service and treatment and is very knowledgeable about training dogs using positive reinforcement and a force-free approach. As a Certified Dog Trainer (CCDT), Dani graduated from CATCH Canine Trainer Academy’s Master Course program.
    Professional Dog Trainer
    Expert Answer
    Yes—using a prong collar incorrectly could really scar your dog. You want to make sure you're working with a professional dog trainer so they can show you the correct way to use it.
  • Question
    Why should I use a prong collar if it has been banned in 13 countries?
    Community Answer
    The prong collar has been banned in 13 countries? The prong collar can be more humane than the so-called "choke chain." A choke chain, used inappropriately, can crush a dog's trachea, requiring corrective surgery. Prong collars aren't likely to cause that kind of damage because of how they are engineered. Prong collars pinch instead of crushing.
  • Question
    What is average amount of time to use a prong collar?
    Community Answer
    Some people use it for less than a week but others use it for 6 months or more. It depends on the dog.
  • Question
    Do I need to clip both rings to the leash at the same time?
    Community Answer
    No. Only clip the leash to one ring. On some collars, this is a D-Ring; on others, it is an O-Ring.
  • Question
    What size prong collars should 50-60 pound dogs wear?
    Community Answer
    Small: 12” - 15” Neck; Medium: 15” - 21” Neck; Large: 17” - 23” Neck; Extra Large: 19” - 25” Neck.
  • Question
    We have been using the poke collar on morning walks with our 11-month-old Newfie, who weighs 130 lbs. A few mornings ago he bolted after a squirrel and I had to let go. Is the collar to loose maybe?
    Community Answer
    I highly doubt it, but I would tighten just a bit. Make sure the clip is on top of the dog's neck so that the prongs make them uncomfortable and they don't pull. If you need to, pull on the leash if they continue pulling.
  • Question
    What is the best no-pull dog harness for a strong dog?
    Community Answer
    Harnesses that have a clip at the chest work best. Just make sure they fit snugly, because loose ones can fall off or be escaped from.
  • Question
    What's the easiest way to add or remove a prong?
    Community Answer
    Using pliers will help you spread and close the collar with ease.
  • Question
    I got a new prong collar and it has rubber tips. Do I remove these tips?
    Community Answer
    These rubber tips are to nullify the shock power, meaning it won't hurt as much. These are supposed to be on for the first days, but then you take them off. Consider them the training wheels to a bike.
  • Question
    Should a prog collar not be used to suppress a dog jumping up on people? The write-up implies it should be used only in training sessions.
    Amateur Progressive reinforcement trainer
    Top Answerer
    Dogs jump on people due to excitement. Introducing intimidation and punishment (the collar) will not suppress the excitement; in fact it could make things worse, encouraging fear to develop, and fear evokes powerful emotions, such as aggression. I recommend teaching your dog to be calm in those situations and teaching 'the calm settle' which can be found on Youtube. If your dog is not over aroused then they'll have no motivation to jump in the presence of other people.
  • Question
    I like to unhook the collar instead of slipping it over the dog's head. Should I use different links to hook and unhook it? Or should I use the same link repeatedly?
    Community Answer
    You're supposed to unlink and link it back together around your dog's neck instead of pulling it over, which could harm your dog. That's why they're also called pinch collars, and no, when you find the comfortable fit on your dog when the collar is on, you use the same links already on the collar. If you were to use a different link to attach the collar, (let's say a link that isn't the same as the others such as size wise), you'll mess up what pressure is distributed around the neck. You can order more links of the same size if the collar feels too tight on the dog's neck, and if the collar is too loose around your dog's neck then you would remove/take off some of the links on the prong.
  • Question
    Removed a couple prongs from my new prong collar. Seemed too tight then, but then I added a prong back and it seems too loose, the collar was moving a lot. How do I know if it's too tight for my dog?
    Community Answer
    You should be able to fit one finger under a link on the prong. Another way to see if it's too tight is if your dog seems more uncomfortable and tries to shake it off when you're walking or if it slips down their neck while you're walking, you can tell that it's too loose.
  • Question
    I am training my 9 month old pit bull on walks will pull and pull and I have to give her a couple good yanks, one time pulling her almost over before she stops. What am I doing wrong?
    StandardPoodler49
    Community Answer
    It seems like the dog is oblivious to it. Try another method of training. It sounds like a gentle leader won't work either, so consult a professional dog trainer.
  • Question
    I have a Doberman. When I use a prong collar it slides down his neck. It fits correctly. I could’t possibly remove another link. What can I do?
    Community Answer
    Try to keep the tension on his leash so it doesn't slip down and when/if it does slip down, make him stop so that you can correct it. You might also try using a harness and regular collar.
  • Question
    How tight should the prong collar be? Is it okay if I can get a finger under it?
    Community Answer
    It should be tight enough that it doesn't slip around on the dog's neck. If it is moving around, then remove a prong.
  • Question
    Can I slip the prong collar over my dog's head? Should I detach the prong and slip it around the neck and reattach the prong?
    Community Answer
    Do not slip the collar over the dogs head. You could accidentally injure the dog. If you can slip it over the dog's, head the prong collar has not been fit properly to your dog.
Ask a Question

      Return to Full Article